Is Hugo Chavez' regime in Venezuela a dictatorship? Is it a democracy? Is it neither?

Start writing your answer after the instructions

Instructions

  1. Consider evidence from both sides. Note that the debate over this question has become quite polarised; you need to think critically about your sources, whether pro or anti Chavez.
  2. Take into account the fact that there may have been changes in the regime since Chavez took power in 1999. Has Venezuela become more (less) authoritarian since Chavez took power, even if it is not (yet) a dictatorship?
  3. Consider the possibility that Venezuela may not be either a democracy or a dictatorship. If it is neither (or has become neither), how should we classify its current regime?

Resources

  1. You should consult first of all at least some of the articles and books tagged "Venezuela" in our course bibliography. Do not simply go looking for random blogs and commentary in the first place! These articles, especially the ones noted in the course outline and included in your course notes, should give you a good sense of the debate about Venezuelan democracy and the broader historical context of Venezuelan politics.
  2. Look also at what relatively respected international organizations say about Venezuela. There are a number of reports worth looking at:
  3. You also need to think about how we should classify political regimes. For this purpose, some of the sources tagged "political regime classifications" or "measurement" in the bibliography might be useful.
  4. Relatedly, you may want to consider how standard regime classifications rank Venezuela since the 1990s (e.g., Polity IV,Freedom House, the DD data by Cheibub, Gandhi and Vreeland, the unified democracy scores, etc.) Are these classifications accurate?
  5. Finally, there are many blogs and websites dedicated to covering Venezuelan politics, from the extremely anti-Chavez to the extremely pro-Chavez.
    • VenezuelAnalysis.com is probably the major pro-Chavez website in English.
    • Caracas Chronicles is a good starting point for looking at opposition blogs in English.
    • You can always look at my delicious feed on Venezuela news and commentary (a collection of web clippings) for more recent news and commentary (note this is biased towards English language and opposition blogs).


Start writing here - do not delete the instructions. Note you can use headers to organize your answer, and do not be afraid to edit other people's writing. This is a wiki! Also, you can use the Discussion page to hash out disagreements.
Is he a dictator.
Hugo Chavez is a man who has changed Venezuela. A country where their was huge social class differences he sought to bring a little equality and soften the difference is wealth between the upper and the lower class. He also introduced a new constitution that guaranteed rights for women and the indigenous people of Venezuela. All and all the start was pretty good, however there has been a fair amount of change in the way he governs which does not show a fair leader at work. Althought does that matter, If under democratic rule the majority of Venesuelan people were unhappy and unable to change anything, would not a governemnt that although is not fair is at least making the counrty better for the majority. The problem is whether a government that is not constrained will actually continue to make things better! There is also a fair amount of debate about whether Chavez is actually making things better for the majority - see some of the sources mentioned above. Also please proofread! - xmarquez xmarquez Mar 15, 2011